SW Community
Closed Strip Club

Red Garter Saloon

Key West, FL 208 Duval St (305) 296-4964
Closed
Strip Club Topless 21+
Hours
Hours not published.
On tap
VIP Rooms
57/100

Duval Street stage dive; Eastern European roster, low cover weekdays, tight quarters.

Red Garter trades on Duval Street foot traffic and a tight, lively room packed with Eastern European talent. Weekday cover is free or $5; weekends jump to $20. Reviewers consistently praise the dancers' friendliness and looks, though some note aggressive upselling. The space is small and narrow—you sit close to the stage and other patrons—which kills privacy but feeds the party vibe. Best for bachelor groups and casual drinkers who want stage entertainment without pretense.

How this is scored
57/100

Long narrow room on main strip; street parking scarce, two stages and bars, compact seating.

Located dead-center on Duval Street near Rick's Entertainment Complex, so you're steps from bars and foot traffic but parking is street-only and scarce. The club is long and narrow with two stages and two bars; one back section sometimes closes on slow nights. Seating is tight—mostly bar stools at stage height—so you're in the action but packed in. No parking lot, no frills, no privacy; it's a fishbowl by design.

How property is scored
HOW PROPERTY IS SCORED

Property weighting

Property weighs 7 sub-metrics — atmosphere, location, privacy, parking, luxury, amenities, capacity — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 property score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

PROPERTY · 57/100

The room

Long narrow room on main strip; street parking scarce, two stages and bars, compact seating.

Located dead-center on Duval Street near Rick's Entertainment Complex, so you're steps from bars and foot traffic but parking is street-only and scarce. The club is long and narrow with two stages and two bars; one back section sometimes closes on slow nights. Seating is tight—mostly bar stools at stage height—so you're in the action but packed in. No parking lot, no frills, no privacy; it's a fishbowl by design.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Atmosphere 8.0
  • Location 8.0
  • Privacy 4.3
  • Parking 2.0
  • Luxury 2.1
  • Amenities 5.1
  • Capacity 6.0
60/100

Friendly staff and bartenders; quick door process, no-cover Mon–Thu, weekend cover climbs to $20.

Bartenders and door staff are friendly and efficient. No cover Mon–Thu (or $5 depending on season), $20 Fri–Sat. Security is a quick wand, no hassle. Drinks come fast. Respect is solid; no reports of hostility or disrespect. The tradeoff: it's a high-volume, party-first environment, not a lounge.

How service is scored
HOW SERVICE IS SCORED

Service weighting

Service weighs 7 sub-metrics — door, bar, speed, respect, safety, clean, value — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 service score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

SERVICE · 60/100

The hospitality

Friendly staff and bartenders; quick door process, no-cover Mon–Thu, weekend cover climbs to $20.

Bartenders and door staff are friendly and efficient. No cover Mon–Thu (or $5 depending on season), $20 Fri–Sat. Security is a quick wand, no hassle. Drinks come fast. Respect is solid; no reports of hostility or disrespect. The tradeoff: it's a high-volume, party-first environment, not a lounge.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Door service 6.0
  • Bar service 6.0
  • Speed 5.1
  • Respect 6.8
  • Safety 6.0
  • Cleanliness 6.0
  • Value 6.0
55/100

Cheap beer ($4–$6), mixed drinks around $8; no real food; bottle prices steep ($20+).

No food. Beer runs $4–$6, mixed drinks $8. Bottle prices are steep ($20+). Reviewers note drinks are cheaper on Duval Street itself, so grab a cocktail outside and bring it in if allowed. This is a beer-and-tip room, not a dining destination.

How food is scored
HOW FOOD IS SCORED

Food weighting

Food weighs 7 sub-metrics — quality, price, drinks, bottles, luxury, cigar, value — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 food score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

FOOD · 55/100

The kitchen

Cheap beer ($4–$6), mixed drinks around $8; no real food; bottle prices steep ($20+).

No food. Beer runs $4–$6, mixed drinks $8. Bottle prices are steep ($20+). Reviewers note drinks are cheaper on Duval Street itself, so grab a cocktail outside and bring it in if allowed. This is a beer-and-tip room, not a dining destination.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Food quality 1.0
  • Food prices 1.0
  • Drink prices 8.0
  • Bottle prices 4.3
  • Luxury 2.1
  • Cigars & hookah 1.0
  • Value 6.0
56/100

Eastern European dancers dominate; friendly but aggressive sales pitch; $20–$25 per song, full contact.

Eastern European dancers are the calling card—multiple reviewers mention Russian and Eastern European talent, often described as stunning and friendly. Roster is small (3–5 on slow days, 20+ when busy), so talent varies with shift. Dances run $20–$25 per song, full contact. The main gripe: dancers are aggressive in their sales pitch, approaching repeatedly and moving on quickly if you decline. Best to arrive early or off-peak if you want a relaxed vibe.

How performers is scored
HOW PERFORMERS IS SCORED

Performers weighting

Performers weighs 6 sub-metrics — talent, style, interact, pro, vip, dance — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 performers score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

PERFORMERS · 56/100

The floor

Eastern European dancers dominate; friendly but aggressive sales pitch; $20–$25 per song, full contact.

Eastern European dancers are the calling card—multiple reviewers mention Russian and Eastern European talent, often described as stunning and friendly. Roster is small (3–5 on slow days, 20+ when busy), so talent varies with shift. Dances run $20–$25 per song, full contact. The main gripe: dancers are aggressive in their sales pitch, approaching repeatedly and moving on quickly if you decline. Best to arrive early or off-peak if you want a relaxed vibe.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Talent quality 6.0
  • Appearance & style 6.0
  • Interaction 6.0
  • Professionalism 4.2
  • VIP value 5.1
  • Dance value 6.0
HOW IT'S SCORED

Overall SW Score weighting

Each point on the radar is a dimension scored 0–100, weighted by how much it shapes a night out. Balanced shapes mean well-rounded clubs; spikes mean a venue excels at one thing but not others.

Tap any dimension's own info icon to see which sub-metrics feed into it.

SW SCORE · 57/100

How scoring works

Duval Street stage dive; Eastern European roster, low cover weekdays, tight quarters.

Red Garter trades on Duval Street foot traffic and a tight, lively room packed with Eastern European talent. Weekday cover is free or $5; weekends jump to $20. Reviewers consistently praise the dancers' friendliness and looks, though some note aggressive upselling. The space is small and narrow—you sit close to the stage and other patrons—which kills privacy but feeds the party vibe. Best for bachelor groups and casual drinkers who want stage entertainment without pretense.

SW Score is a weighted composite across four dimensions — property, service, food, and performers — measured across 27 sub-metrics and a separate value score.

Sub-metric signals are pulled from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. Each dimension rolls up into a 0-100 score, which feeds the weighted overall.

How to read the shape: a balanced radar means a well-rounded club. A spiked shape means it excels at one thing and not others. Tap any dimension below for its full breakdown.

Dimension scores
  • Property 57
  • Service 60
  • Food 55
  • Performers 56
  • Value 59
Rate this club

Your take, one tap at a time.

A quick 6-step walkthrough — 4 categories of spiderweb ratings plus a written review at the end. Takes about 2 minutes.

0 of 27 rated

What the floor said

25 reviews
90/100 SW score
Bachelors' Party Delight The Red Garter Saloon was the perfect spot for my bachelor party. The atmosphere was electric, with multiple stages and a lively dance floor. Drinks were affordable and the dancers were talented. Only downside was the parking, but it was worth it for the fun we had.
70/100 SW score
Mixed Bag I stopped by the Red Garter on a Tuesday night, hoping for a low-key evening. The location was great, but the parking was a nightmare. The dancers were okay, but the VIP room was a bit overpriced. Overall, it was an average experience.
50/100 SW score
Not Impressed As a local, I've been to my fair share of strip clubs, but the Red Garter fell short. The atmosphere was lacking sophistication, and the drinks were overpriced. The only redeeming quality was the respect the dancers showed, but it wasn't enough to make up for the rest.
Read all 25 reviews — members only
Create a free account to read every real review on every club, plus VIP offers near you.
Offers Directions